There are times when I disagree with the general consensus on Rotten Tomatoes. In fact, this is a very often occurrence. Unfortunately, when I sat down to watch "The Spirit" yesterday, it was not one of those times.
I am not alone in thinking "The Spirit" was a terrible, terrible movie. The writing was absolutely horrific. I've never heard so much expository dialog in my life. The action was ordinary at best, whenever it got around to finally whipping up any semblance of motion. The plot was overly simple, to the point that a child could summarize every event in 30 seconds flat. But the worst part, the part that really pissed me off, was the characters.
Now, I know I've already said the writing is bad, but sometimes good characters are given bad lines. Sometimes a good, funny, or memorable character can redeem an otherwise floundering storyline. "The Spirit" didn't even have one. The worst of the worst was the way each and every woman character was written and acted. I'm not normally sensitive to that kind of thing, being a male who is usually content to watch other males kick ass. Don't get me wrong; it's way cooler to watch women kick ass, as it is a far rarer sight. I wish I could've said that about any one of the women in "The Spirit". One of the actresses made the laughable statement that all the women characters in this disgusting mess of a film are too strong and intelligent to need rescuing like you might expect. Oh sure, none of them are the typical "damsel in distress", but let me paint you a picture. This actress's character was a doctor, which requires intellect, oh yes. Then we see the Spirit has some nonsensical power plucked straight from every womanizer's dream: he "knows just what to say" to make any and every woman desperately love him. There's no plot-driven reason for the Spirit to posses such a power or skill or whatever. It doesn't even make sense within the context of the story. So this supposedly strong, intelligent doctor not only knows he "truly loves every woman", but actually sees him sucking the face off the secondary antagonist, and what does she do? Mutter "Bastard!" so he can hear, then give this little smirk like she's still crazy about him anyway. And that antagonist, Miss Sand Seraf? She's supposed to be "strong" just because she can wave a gun around and chase after everything shiny? I'm dead serious, that's her character motivation: she wants shiny things. Don't even get me started on Scarlet Johannson's character. *spoiler, though you really shouldn't care* I mean, I thought she'd show enough intelligence to steal the immortality formula and drink the blood herself, betraying the doctor and becoming the real villan that the Spirit would have to somehow bring himself to defeat. See what I did there? That's not even an unpredictable plot twist! But no, she's just this bubblegum-for-brains dupe following...what? Orders? Right to the so-predictable-it's-almost-unexpected end? */spoiler*
Frank Miller, you've done some cool things, but you wouldn't know a strong woman if one spent the rest the rest of your life kicking you in the balls (which I would highly encourage). Queen Gorgo was good, but I don't think she was even in the 300 comic, and you had absolutely dick to to do with the movie. Am I being ignorant here? Would any self-respecting, intelligent, strong woman really devote herself to a man she knows is unfaithful? Repeatedly, publicly, unapologetically unfaithful? Do strong women really become completely selfish, trecherous bitches just to obtain all things sparkly? Did anybody else see this atrocity of a movie and actually find something compelling in it?
Soon, I will be off to see G.I. Joe, a movie I hope will be awful in an awesome way, instead of just absolutely sickness-inducing.